Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Meat Lovers Pizza (Large)
Salmon With Chef's Choice Vegetables
Italian Combo Wrap
Chicken Bacon Cheddar Wrap
About
Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant (Matamoras)
Welcome to Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant in the charming town of Matamoras, Pennsylvania. Nestled at 111 Hulst Dr, this delightful eatery promises an unforgettable dining experience that captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. With a reputation for serving some of the best pizzas in the region, Goodfella's has quickly become a beloved culinary gem among locals and visitors alike.
Stepping inside, you'll find a warm and inviting atmosphere that blends casual comfort with a touch of Italian flair. Many patrons have lauded the clean and welcoming environment, complete with unique art pieces that beautify the walls and an outdoor seating area that beckons on pleasant days. As one customer noted, it feels more like a standalone restaurant than one nestled in a strip mall, showcasing its commitment to quality and style.
Now, let’s talk about the food! The menu at Goodfella's is an ode to classic Italian fare, featuring a selection of specialty pizzas that cater to every palate. The Deluxe White Pizza, a personal-sized triumph, comes with a smear of seasoned ricotta, topped with a melty blend of mozzarella and pecorino Romano, all drizzled with garlic oil for that perfect touch of flavor. For those craving something heartier, the BBQ Chicken Pizza satisfies with its generous portions of breaded chicken smothered in BBQ sauce and crowned with both mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
Appetizers like the Fried Calamari Rings are a must-try, and the Mozzarella Sticks are a guilty pleasure—crispy and golden, bursting with gooey cheese. Whether you're dining in or enjoying a meal to-go, the portions are hearty and certainly encourage sharing, as John C. remarked about the family-style servings that deliver on both flavor and satisfaction.
Not only does Goodfella's excel in quality, but the staff also ensures an exceptional dining experience. Reviewers have praised servers like Ethan for their attentiveness and friendliness, creating an inviting service atmosphere that enhances the meal experience. The blend of quality service and excellent cuisine appeals greatly to food lovers.
In summary, Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant is more than just a spot to grab a meal; it’s a place where passion for Italian food meets quality service in an inviting ambiance. For anyone in the Matamoras area, this restaurant is a culinary destination worth visiting. Whether you're sharing stories over a large slice of pizza or enjoying a cozy meal at the table, Goodfella's surely leaves a lasting impression that will have you coming back for more!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Overall an excellent experience. I reserve the right to come back and edit this later though! I ordered a bunch of stuff to go for other family members. The pizza is huge, as you can see from the pictures. The brown and white pizza is a stuffed barbequed chicken pizza my daughter ordered. She was able to eat ONE slice. Lol I got the two slices, plain and the "Captains". I could not finish the second slice, and I am a big eater! The waitress was very helpful and patient. The staff were all friendly. The place was very clean. The atmosphere was surprisingly nice! It had a little outdoor seating area and very nice ambiance. Nice art on the walls, both murals and pictures. This seemed more like a stand alone restaurant than a place in a "strip mall". I think they far outclass the rest of the tenants here. My daughter has raved about this place for quite a while, so I brought her today so I could try it. Back to the pizza.... for some background, I was a pizza man when I was younger and ran a pizzeria. I am VERY picky. The first thing I will say is this is the best pizza I ever had in Pennsylvania. But that's a low bar to overcome. The crust was excellent. Excellent. The cheese and toppings were fine. The sauce was the only thing I was not a huge fan of. It's not that it was bad, and this is COMPLETELY subjective of course. It was the weak point to me for sure. That's the only negative I have, and it's really not negative. Just a matter of taste. ”
“ Our server Ethan was the best!! He was friendly, attentive and contentious. Food is always fantastic. We had the portobello mushroom ravioli and the chicken parm. Try their blue cheese dressing, it is worth the visit by itself. ”
“ very quite and professional environment. judge by what you see if you must, the cheese was so stringy, that it would stretch for miles. the taste of the chicken bacon ranch pizza was perfectly cooked, toppings were placed perfect at each bite i felt more and more inspiration as i was eating. ”
“ Food is definitely family style. You get a lot of food and it has great flavor. My only complaint is that they had a light in the dining room that flashed like it was a strobe and was very distracting. Hope by now they have fixed it. Other than that, bring your 'A' game because the food is good. Enjoy. ”
“ We stopped in the area for an overnight stay and ordered delivery to the hotel. The food was excellent; veal parm sandwich, bruschetta and spaghetti with meatball! From the time order was placed and delivered the customer service was phenomenal! Will definitely order again when we are in the area! Thank you to all! ”
“ BEST pizza I’ve ever had I just moved to the area tried a few pizza places but they were all of that thin soggy pizza. THIS PLACE HAS THICK ROBUST PIZZA!!!! So beautifully crafted. THE GRALIC KNOTS ARE NOT DRY AT ALL. I will be coming back here a lot. They always have a bar which is very cool. Everything is definitely worth the price. ”
“ I recently had my daughter’s 16th birthday party in the bistro room. The service was superb, food was AMAZING and the room itself is beautiful. Highly recommended hosting an event there. Anthony and Karen were amazing and Doug is THE BEST pizza guy around! Thank you!! ”
“ There were 4 of us who went to eat around 730pm on a Friday night.We walked in and were sat immediately. The tables were full and they were a bit busy. We got our drinks and looked at the menu. There is food on there for everyone. Vegetarian to a meat lover. Our waitress wasn't the friendliest, but I think they were short staffed. Two of the people ordered pizza..one ordered a meat lovers roll, I got creamy parmesan rice pilaf with shrimp. We all enjoyed our food. You get a lot of it for your money! The slices are like 2 regular slice pizzas in one. The personal size pizza is a regular medium pizza,and the roll is like a calzone but in roll form, and everyone knows what rice pilaf is. Pictures show what I'm talking about. ”